E-cigarette Study Finds Potential Benefits and Risks
A comprehensive new study on electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes) has found that while they may help some smokers quit or reduce their smoking, they also pose potential health risks, especially for youth and young adults. The study, conducted by researchers at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF), reviewed over 800 scientific papers on e-cigarettes and synthesized the findings to provide an up-to-date assessment of the evidence.
Study Highlights Potential Benefits of E-cigarettes for Adult Smokers
One of the key findings of the study is that e-cigarettes may be an effective tool for helping adult smokers quit or reduce their smoking. The researchers found that e-cigarettes, when used as a complete substitute for traditional cigarettes, can reduce exposure to many of the harmful chemicals found in tobacco smoke.
“Our review found that e-cigarettes, while not risk-free, are likely to be much less harmful than combustible tobacco cigarettes,” said Dr. Stanton Glantz, one of the study’s authors and director of the UCSF Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education. “For smokers who are unable or unwilling to quit using other methods, switching completely to e-cigarettes could reduce their health risks.”
The study cites several randomized controlled trials that have found e-cigarettes to be effective for smoking cessation. For example, a 2019 study published in the New England Journal of Medicine found that e-cigarettes were nearly twice as effective as nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) for helping smokers quit.
| Study | E-cigarette Quit Rate | NRT Quit Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Hajek et al. (2019) | 18% | 9.9% |
| Bullen et al. (2013) | 7.3% | 5.8% |
| Caponnetto et al. (2013) | 8.7% | 4% |
However, the authors caution that the long-term health effects of e-cigarette use are still unknown, and that more research is needed to fully understand the potential risks and benefits.
E-cigarettes Pose Risks, Especially for Youth and Young Adults
While e-cigarettes may offer some benefits for adult smokers, the study highlights several potential risks, particularly for youth and young adults. The researchers found that e-cigarette use among these populations has risen dramatically in recent years, and that e-cigarettes are now the most commonly used tobacco product among U.S. youth.
“Our review found that e-cigarette use among youth and young adults is associated with an increased risk of ever using combustible tobacco cigarettes,” said Dr. Glantz. “This is concerning because it suggests that e-cigarettes may be acting as a gateway to traditional smoking for some young people.”
The study cites data from the 2019 National Youth Tobacco Survey, which found that 27.5% of high school students and 10.5% of middle school students reported current e-cigarette use. This represents a significant increase from 2018, when the rates were 20.8% and 4.9%, respectively.
| Year | High School E-cigarette Use | Middle School E-cigarette Use |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | 27.5% | 10.5% |
| 2018 | 20.8% | 4.9% |
| 2017 | 11.7% | 3.3% |
| 2016 | 11.3% | 4.3% |
The authors also note that e-cigarettes contain nicotine, which is highly addictive and can harm brain development in young people. They cite studies showing that youth who use e-cigarettes are more likely to report symptoms of nicotine dependence than those who do not use them.
In addition to the risks for youth, the study highlights potential health risks for all e-cigarette users. While e-cigarettes generally contain fewer toxic chemicals than traditional cigarettes, they still expose users to harmful substances such as ultrafine particles, heavy metals, and volatile organic compounds.
The researchers also note that e-cigarette use has been associated with acute lung injuries and deaths, particularly those related to THC-containing products. In 2019, an outbreak of e-cigarette or vaping product use-associated lung injury (EVALI) resulted in over 2,800 hospitalizations and 68 deaths in the United States.
Regulation of E-cigarettes Varies Widely
The study also highlights the complex regulatory landscape surrounding e-cigarettes. While the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has regulatory authority over e-cigarettes, the authors note that regulation varies widely across countries and even within the United States.
“Our review found that e-cigarette regulation is inconsistent and often lags behind the rapidly evolving market,” said Dr. Glantz. “This creates challenges for policymakers and public health officials who are trying to protect public health while also considering the potential benefits for adult smokers.”
In the United States, e-cigarettes are regulated as tobacco products under the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act. This means that e-cigarette manufacturers must submit premarket tobacco product applications (PMTAs) to the FDA in order to continue selling their products.
However, the authors note that the FDA has struggled to keep up with the rapidly growing e-cigarette market, and that many products remain on the market without having undergone FDA review. They also point out that some states and localities have implemented their own e-cigarette regulations, such as banning flavored products or restricting sales to minors.
Future Research Needs
The study concludes by outlining several areas where further research is needed to fully understand the potential benefits and risks of e-cigarettes. These include:
- Long-term health effects of e-cigarette use
- Efficacy of e-cigarettes for smoking cessation in real-world settings
- Impact of e-cigarette use on youth and young adult smoking initiation
- Role of flavors and other product characteristics in e-cigarette use and appeal
- Optimal regulatory strategies for maximizing benefits and minimizing risks
“While our review provides a comprehensive assessment of the current evidence on e-cigarettes, there is still much we don’t know,” said Dr. Glantz. “Continued research and surveillance will be critical for informing public health policy and helping individuals make informed decisions about their health.”
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. Are e-cigarettes safe?
E-cigarettes are not risk-free, but they are generally considered to be less harmful than traditional cigarettes. However, the long-term health effects of e-cigarette use are still unknown, and they can still expose users to harmful substances such as nicotine, ultrafine particles, and heavy metals.
2. Can e-cigarettes help smokers quit?
Some studies have found that e-cigarettes can be effective for helping smokers quit or reduce their smoking, particularly when used as a complete substitute for traditional cigarettes. However, the evidence is mixed, and more research is needed to fully understand the potential benefits and risks.
3. Are e-cigarettes regulated by the FDA?
Yes, e-cigarettes are regulated as tobacco products under the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act. Manufacturers must submit premarket tobacco product applications (PMTAs) to the FDA in order to continue selling their products. However, regulation varies widely across countries and even within the United States.
4. What are the risks of e-cigarette use for youth and young adults?
E-cigarette use among youth and young adults has risen dramatically in recent years, and it is associated with an increased risk of ever using traditional cigarettes. E-cigarettes also contain nicotine, which is highly addictive and can harm brain development in young people. Youth who use e-cigarettes are more likely to report symptoms of nicotine dependence than those who do not use them.
5. What are the most common side effects of e-cigarette use?
The most common side effects of e-cigarette use include mouth and throat irritation, cough, and nausea. More serious side effects, such as lung injuries and seizures, have also been reported in some cases. It is important to note that the long-term health effects of e-cigarette use are still unknown, and more research is needed to fully understand the potential risks.
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” alt=”” class=”wp-image-136″ >
