Bare Board Testing

Posted by

What is a Bare Board?

A bare board, also known as a printed circuit board (PCB) without components, is the foundation of any electronic device. It consists of a non-conductive substrate, typically made of fiberglass or other composite materials, with conductive copper traces, pads, and vias etched onto its surface. These conductive elements form the electrical connections between the various components that will be soldered onto the board during the assembly process.

Bare boards are manufactured through a multi-step process that includes:

  1. Designing the PCB layout using specialized software
  2. Printing the design onto a photoresist layer
  3. Etching away the unwanted copper
  4. Drilling holes for through-hole components and vias
  5. Applying a protective solder mask and silkscreen layer

Importance of Bare Board Quality

The quality of a bare board is crucial to the overall performance and reliability of the final electronic product. Any defects or imperfections in the PCB can lead to malfunctions, short circuits, or even complete failure of the device. Therefore, it is essential to ensure that bare boards are thoroughly tested and inspected before they proceed to the assembly stage.

Bare Board Testing Methods

There are several methods used to test and inspect bare boards for defects and quality issues. These methods can be broadly categorized into two groups: electrical tests and visual inspections.

Electrical Tests

Electrical tests are performed to verify the continuity and isolation of the copper traces, pads, and vias on the bare board. These tests ensure that the electrical connections are intact and there are no short circuits or open circuits present. Some common electrical tests include:

1. Flying Probe Test

Flying probe testing is an automated method that uses movable test probes to make contact with specific points on the bare board. The probes are guided by a computer-controlled system that follows the PCB layout data. Flying probe tests can check for:

  • Continuity between connected points
  • Isolation between unconnected points
  • Resistance values of traces and vias
  • Capacitance between layers
Advantages Disadvantages
Flexible and programmable Slower than other electrical tests
No custom fixtures required Limited to exposed test points
Ideal for prototype and low-volume testing Higher cost per board

2. Bed of Nails Test

Bed of nails testing uses a custom-built fixture with spring-loaded pins (nails) that make contact with the test points on the bare board. The fixture is designed specifically for each PCB layout and is connected to a test system that performs the electrical tests. Bed of nails tests can check for:

  • Continuity between connected points
  • Isolation between unconnected points
  • Resistance values of traces and vias
  • Dielectric strength between layers
Advantages Disadvantages
Fast and efficient for high-volume testing Requires custom fixtures for each PCB design
Can test multiple boards simultaneously Limited flexibility for design changes
Lower cost per board for large quantities Higher initial setup costs

3. Boundary Scan Test

Boundary scan testing, also known as JTAG (Joint Test Action Group) testing, is a method that uses built-in test circuitry within the integrated circuits (ICs) on the board. This test circuitry allows access to the input and output pins of the ICs, enabling the tester to control and monitor the signals at the boundary of each IC. Boundary scan tests can check for:

  • Continuity and isolation of traces connected to IC pins
  • Correct operation of ICs and their interconnections
  • Programming and verification of programmable devices
Advantages Disadvantages
Tests complex digital circuits Limited to boards with JTAG-compatible ICs
Provides access to internal nodes of ICs Requires specialized software and hardware
Can be used for in-system programming May not cover all aspects of the board

Visual Inspections

Visual inspections are performed to identify surface defects, such as scratches, pits, or contamination, as well as dimensional issues, like incorrect hole sizes or spacing. These inspections can be done manually by trained operators or automatically using machine vision systems.

1. Manual Visual Inspection

Manual visual inspection involves a human operator examining the bare board under magnification, using a microscope or high-resolution camera. The operator checks for visible defects and compares the board to the PCB layout data. Manual inspection can detect:

  • Surface defects (e.g., scratches, pits, contamination)
  • Dimensional issues (e.g., incorrect hole sizes, spacing)
  • Cosmetic flaws (e.g., color variations, markings)
Advantages Disadvantages
Flexible and adaptable to different board designs Slow and labor-intensive
Can identify a wide range of defects Prone to human error and subjectivity
Relatively low equipment costs Difficulty in maintaining consistent quality

2. Automated Optical Inspection (AOI)

Automated optical inspection uses machine vision systems with high-resolution cameras and image processing software to scan the bare board and compare it to the PCB layout data. AOI systems can detect:

  • Surface defects (e.g., scratches, pits, contamination)
  • Dimensional issues (e.g., incorrect hole sizes, spacing)
  • Pattern and artwork errors (e.g., missing or incorrect traces, pads)
Advantages Disadvantages
Fast and consistent inspection High initial equipment costs
Programmable for different board designs Limited to visible surface defects
Generates detailed defect reports May require fine-tuning for each PCB design

Implementing a Bare Board Testing Strategy

To ensure the quality and reliability of bare boards, it is essential to implement a comprehensive testing strategy that combines both electrical tests and visual inspections. The specific tests and inspections used will depend on factors such as the complexity of the PCB design, the volume of production, and the reliability requirements of the final product.

Factors to Consider

When developing a bare board testing strategy, consider the following factors:

  1. PCB design complexity: More complex designs may require additional testing methods or increased coverage.
  2. Production volume: High-volume production may benefit from automated testing methods to improve efficiency and consistency.
  3. Reliability requirements: Critical applications may demand more stringent testing and inspection criteria.
  4. Cost and time constraints: Testing methods should be selected to balance the need for quality with the available budget and schedule.

Best Practices

To optimize the effectiveness of bare board testing, follow these best practices:

  1. Develop a clear and comprehensive test plan that defines the specific tests and inspections to be performed, as well as the acceptance criteria for each.
  2. Use a combination of electrical tests and visual inspections to cover a wide range of potential defects.
  3. Regularly calibrate and maintain testing equipment to ensure accurate and consistent results.
  4. Train personnel on the proper use of testing equipment and inspection techniques.
  5. Document and analyze test results to identify trends and opportunities for process improvement.


1. What is the difference between a bare board and a printed circuit board assembly (PCBA)?

A bare board is a printed circuit board without any components soldered onto it. A PCBA, on the other hand, is a bare board that has undergone the assembly process, where electronic components are soldered onto the board to create a functional circuit.

2. Can bare board testing detect all possible defects?

While bare board testing is designed to identify a wide range of defects, it may not detect every possible issue. Some defects, such as internal delamination or sub-surface voids, may not be detectable by standard electrical tests or visual inspections. However, a comprehensive testing strategy can help minimize the risk of defective boards progressing to the assembly stage.

3. How much does bare board testing cost?

The cost of bare board testing varies depending on factors such as the complexity of the PCB design, the testing methods used, and the volume of production. In general, automated testing methods like flying probe and AOI have higher initial equipment costs but can be more cost-effective for high-volume production. Manual testing methods may have lower upfront costs but can be more labor-intensive and time-consuming.

4. Is bare board testing required for all PCB designs?

The decision to perform bare board testing depends on the specific requirements of the PCB design and the final application. Some simple, low-risk designs may not require extensive testing, while complex, high-reliability designs may demand a rigorous testing strategy. Ultimately, the decision should be based on a careful assessment of the potential risks and benefits.

5. Can bare board testing be outsourced to a third-party provider?

Yes, many companies choose to outsource their bare board testing to specialized service providers. These providers typically have the necessary equipment, expertise, and certifications to perform a wide range of testing and inspection services. Outsourcing can be a cost-effective option for companies that do not have the in-house resources or expertise to perform bare board testing themselves.


Bare board testing is a critical step in ensuring the quality and reliability of printed circuit boards. By identifying defects and imperfections before the assembly process, manufacturers can minimize the risk of costly rework, delays, and product failures. A comprehensive testing strategy that combines electrical tests and visual inspections can help detect a wide range of potential issues, from continuity and isolation problems to surface defects and dimensional issues.

When developing a bare board testing strategy, it is essential to consider factors such as PCB design complexity, production volume, reliability requirements, and cost and time constraints. By following best practices and regularly reviewing and optimizing their testing processes, manufacturers can improve the overall quality and efficiency of their PCB Production.

As electronic devices continue to become more complex and sophisticated, the importance of bare board testing will only continue to grow. By investing in the right testing methods and technologies, manufacturers can position themselves to meet the evolving demands of the industry and deliver high-quality, reliable products to their customers.